Integrate > Workshops and Webinars > Teaching about Risk and Resilience > Real-world Example Collection > Earthquake Scenarios: Evaluating Potential Ground Shaking and Damage

Earthquake Scenarios: Evaluating Potential Ground Shaking and Damage

Carla Whittington, Physical Science (Geology Program), Highline Community College

Summary

The Pacific Northwest lies along a convergent plate boundary called the Cascadia Subduction Zone. Within this tectonic setting there are three sources of earthquakes: 1) Subduction zone interface earthquakes can occur where the Juan de Fuca plate plunges beneath the North American plate, 2) Deep earthquakes can issue from the Juan de Fuca plate as it passes underneath the North American continent, and 3) Shallow quakes that occur on faults in the North American Plate. All three sources of earthquakes produce different levels of seismic risk to people living in the Puget Sound lowland. While Subduction Zone Interface earthquakes have the highest potential magnitude (> M.9) and duration of shaking (2-5 minutes), Shallow earthquakes in the North American crust may create the highest intensity of shaking and ground accelerations. Deep earthquakes, while not the highest intensity or magnitude, have the most frequent recurrence intervals (30 years for M. 6 or above). These deep earthquakes can cause significant damage and trigger liquefaction and landslides throughout the region.

As part of an ongoing effort to understand (and reduce) earthquake risk in Washington State, the USGS and other agencies have worked to create ground shaking/intensity scenarios for many of the local crustal faults, as well as the Cascadia subduction zone and deep quakes. For the shaking scenarios, the WA DNR has produced loss-estimates using Hazus-MH, a regional loss estimation tool produced by FEMA. The scenarios and loss estimate data are available through an online GIS portal: the Washington State Hazards Scenario Catalog.

This case study will assess the vulnerablity of individuals and communities to earthquakes from different sources. The Washington State Earthquake Hazards Scenario Catalog can be used by city planners, emergency responders, or individuals (students!) to investigate the potential impacts of earthquakes to their communities and neighborhoods. The scenarios show the shaking intensity expected from each of the three sources and estimates of damage to roadways, bridges, hospitals, schools, and other facilities, as well as underground pipelines, major power lines, and water supplies.


Individuals with expertise/responsibilities in the following areas have helped create the case study:
  • United States Geological Survey (USGS)
  • Washington State Department of Natural Resources (WADNR)
  • Washington Military Department Emergency Management Division (EMD)
  • Huxley College of the Environment's Resilience Institute at Western Washington University (WWU)
  • Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)
  • Cascadia Region Earthquake Worksgroup (CREW)
  • Earthquake Engineering Research Group (EERI)

Key teaching points:
  • The source of an earthquake will impact the amount of shaking felt in an area and the damage done there.
  • Each of the different tectonic sources are anticipated to affect communities in different ways.
  • The earthquake that you fear the most might not be the earthquake that is most likely to cause damage/harm to you or your community.
  • It is possible to identify areas of vulnerability within a community and work to mitigate or reduce the vulnerability.

References:

USGS, 2011, Shakemap Scenarios in the Pacific Northwest, Earthquake Hazards Program.
http://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/shakemap/list.php?s=1&n=pn

Washington State Department of Natural Resources (WA DNR), 2013,Washington State Geological Information Portal, Seismic Scenario Catalog.
http://www.dnr.wa.gov/researchscience/topics/geosciencesdata/pages/geology_portal.aspx

Other Resources:

USGS, 2010, A Magnitude 7.1 Earthquake in the Tacoma Fault Zone, Fact Sheet 2010-3023, pp.4.
http://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/2010/3023/

EERI, 2005, Scenario for a Magnitude 6.7 Earthquake on the Seattle Fault
https://www.eeri.org/projects/earthquake-scenarios/seattle-fault-scenario/

CREW, 2009, Cascadia Shallow Earthquakes
http://www.crew.org/sites/default/files/CREWshallowFinalSmall.pdf

CREW, 2008, Cascadia Deep Earthquakes
http://www.crew.org/sites/default/files/CascDeepEQweb.pdf

CREW, 2013, Cascadia Subduction Zone Earthquakes: A Magnitude 9.0 Earthquake Scenario
http://www.crew.org/sites/default/files/cascadia_subduction_scenario_2013.pdf