Cutting Edge > Hydrogeology > Hydrogeology, Soils, Geochemistry 2013 > Review team instructions

HSG Activity Review Process

Background

The geoscience community has repeatedly asked for access to high-quality, peer-reviewed instructional resources, and we are reviewing assignments and activities in On the Cutting Edge online collections to help meet this need. NSF is also interested in our review process as a model for other education projects.

Review process

Watch the Screencast (Quicktime MP4 Video 92.6MB Apr30 13) of the instructional webinar for reviewers.
The HSG activity review process will take place in two stages:

General procedure for individual reviews (you can also download the PowerPoint slides (PowerPoint 2007 (.pptx) 2.6MB Apr26 13) from the Review Team webinar on April 28):

To help calibrate your expectations, you may find it useful to browse some of the assignments/activities in the Cutting Edge collection that were tagged as exemplary during earlier review activites over the past two years. You'll see a variety of different kinds of activities (field, lab, classroom, back-of-the-envelope calculations).

All of the reviews will be done online using the review tool developed by Sean Fox at SERC.

What happens after you submit your review

Editorial Team

Associate editor page

« Previous Page