Student Motivation and Engagement in Online Courses
by Selby Cull, Washington University in St. Louis
Don Reed, Dept. of Geology, San Jose State University
Karin Kirk, Science Education Resource Center
authored as part of the 2010 workshop, Teaching Geoscience Online - A Workshop for Digital Faculty
- Without face-to-face contact, faculty are not able to pick up nonverbal cues from students that can indicate they are disengaged, frustrated or unenthusiastic.
- Faculty also cannot share their emotions easily and may find it harder to express enthusiasm, encouragement or concern.
- The anonymous feeling of the online environment can make it easier for students to withdraw, participate minimally, or completely disappear from the course.
- Students may enroll in online courses because they feel they will be easier and require less of their time. So before the course even begins, these students may be prone to disengagement.
On the other hand, there are several advantages to the online environment that make it easier to engage students.
- The self-paced nature of online courses allows students to fit the work time into their schedule. Those who prefer to login to the course at midnight are free to do so!
- Extrinsically motivated students can be engaged with quizzes and interactive features that offer instant feedback (need examples, such as the mineral ID lab)
- The web offers tremendous possibilities for flexibility, interactivity and creativity. It is possible to create many types of engaging experiences.
Background: The Nature of Online Learners
Online learners are a varied group, but there are commonalities that can assist instructors in developing effective strategies in course design and pedagogical approach. In particular, these students desire a flexible schedule to achieve their educational goals through self-paced learning while juggling the other demands on their time.
- The requirements of self-paced learning – self discipline, effective time management, writing skills, self-directed work, organization and prioritization of effort, and confidence in presenting ideas openly and recognizing gaps in understanding through self assessment and reflection.
- Type of students we serve - online students range from fast-tracked, high achievers to students currently on academic probation who may take courses through continuing education. The average age of students is generally older and there is higher percentage of female students than in the offering institution as a whole.
- Study habits - many online students have multiple demands on their time, causing odd, sometimes irregular, hours online. Multiple and sometimes competing obligations are squeezed into their daily schedule (other courses, accelerated graduation schedule, work, travel and family), consequently online coursework may not always be their top priority, causing assignments to be pushed aside to last minute, especially in general education courses.
Pedagogic Design for Engagement
- Do not limit your course web pages to blocks of dense text and sparse images. There are many ways to create an engaging design for your course pages. Rely on use of imagery, video, audio, music and interactive features. If possible, work with an instructional designer to create these features.
- Use video of yourself introducing course content, as in this video of Course Information
- Use video of exciting topics in your course, such as this video of the La Conchita Landslide
- Use real-time, web-based data such as USGS streamflow network, NOAA offshore buoy measurements and drifter buoys, recent earthquakes or climate data.
- Have students take on the role of a geoscientist in virtual research activities, patterned after major research initiatives in the geosciences, real-time data or online databases. Example activity - Tracking Drifter Buoys
- Case studies can involve role-playing, the use of maps and data sets and opportunities to synthesize various materials around a central topic (see a collection of 38 role playing scenarios for the classroom)
- Applications of course concepts to your own home town. (such as Environmental Geology of the Area where you Live)
- Ask for students' input on class topics and assignments (Dennis et al. 2007)
- Use of "gateway" assignments, which students must complete before proceeding in the course can be effective in some situations.
- Adopt instructional methods that emphasize "guiding students toward their own discoveries of facts and relationships" (Alutu 2006) (Such as, "While you're reading this assignment, think about how it relates to _____.")
- Use discussion boards to create a sense of community and promote active engagement with the course topics (Using Discussions in an Environmental Geology Course
- Create course topics and readings that are current. Incorporate recent news events and magazine articles into existing course topics (Dennis et al. 2007).
- Assign roles in discussion assignments
, especially for provocative discussions based on current events, case studies or policy issues.
Students are assigned a one-week time period to initiate a discussion about climate change in the news. On their assigned week, the designated student finds a current article that relates to climate change. They start a discussion thread that contains the following:
- Title and URL of article
- Summary of article, written in their own words
- Description of how the article ties in to the course material
- A series of questions for classmates to answer, such as asking for opinion on policy measures, or seeking observations of a certain element of climate change.
- The student then moderates the discussion and responds to their classmates.
- Set up peer groups - extrinsically motivated students are motivated by achievement in relation to their peers; intrinsically motivated students are able to interact with peer groups to gain more insight – both types of students benefit from working in peer groups. (Moore 2006)
- Create a part of the discussion board that is for students only – no instructors allowed.
- Pair the students into "support pairs" with well-defined instructions on how to support each other throughout the course.
- Early on, explicitly model how to give constructive feedback so that students can follow this model.
- Conscious development of metacognition Dennis et al. (2007) suggest posting a primer on metacognition on a discussion thread, and to return to the concept throughout the course. (Find out more about The Role of Metacognition in Teaching Geoscience)
- If possible, hold a face-to-face meeting for a critical activity such as a field trip
Instructor Behavior to Promote EngagementSetting Expectations
- Create explicit course and activity goals (Ames 1992) - students feel more motivated to put effort into a course that they deem worthwhile. If the course goals are explicitly laid out, students can more accurately judge if they are worthwhile.
- Illustrate that you believe students can achieve these goals, and that these are goals worth achieving.
- Illustrate how these goals connect to each other, and to outside topics.
- Periodically ask students to assess their own progress on these goals
- Clearly communicate work/learning expectations before class begins. Using video is an effective way to do this.
- Provide study strategy tips from successful students in previous classes.
- Create a detailed syllabus with assignment information, format of class, course and assignment schedule and advice for completing work . If possible, link assignments and policies directly from the syllabus so students don't have to search for this information.
- Keep the course website updated with notifications of units that are opening, closing or changing.
- Create a short video to initiate each new activity. this provides a personalizes introduction to the work.
- Use a syllabus survey/course policies quiz at beginning of semester, which can be a gateway to assignments (see an example Syllabus Quiz)
- Set up a consistent timetable for work each week , so that deadlines are predictable.
- Log in often, respond quickly, and convey genuine enthusiasm (Crumpacker 2001)
- Because so much communication is done via the typed word, choose your wording to deliberately reach out to students
Let me know if you've got questions.
I'm happy to help with your questions. It's best if you can touch base well before the deadline so we can sort through any questions before the weekend.
- Start a weekly thread on "Tips & Tricks", where students can post suggestions for their classmates.
- Allow students to develop self-efficacy. Recognize when a student has done a particularly good job on a task, or has dramatically improved on a skill. (Kerssen-Griep 2003) "Ensure an early success for each student; praise and document it." (Dennis et al. 2007)
- There are many ways to stay in touch with your students. If you are facile with multiple modes of communication, use whichever one students prefer. Aim for Frequent and regular contact, each week, especially if student is falling behind.
- Try video Skype or video iChat for one-one discussion and interaction
- Set up a Facebook page for your course. This can be a separate Facebook account from your personal page, allowing you to keep your personal page independent from your professional one.
- Encourage personal interactions (Hutchins 2003, Arbaugh 2001)
- Introduce yourself with a photo and an "About Me" blurb
- Ask students to post a photo of themselves, and a blurb about themselves
- Individual students or small groups of students can create web pages or PowerPoint files of images, maps of where they live and topics that interest them. These can be shared with the class via an online gallery walk.
- Carrot (intellectual stimulation) and stick (consistent deadline with clear expectations and consequences with a well-defined late policy for all assignments)
Work turned in late: Assignments are due on the date specified in the course schedule. If you turn in work after a deadline, I will subtract 2 points for each day the assignment is late.
Extensions: If you know you are going to have a conflict, please contact me before the due date to arrange for an extension. In most cases I can give you an extension without any late penalty. If you ask for an extension after the due date, I'll subtract late points from the due date to the date that the extension was requested. Of course, I understand that genuine emergencies do arise. Please keep me in the loop and I will do my best to be understanding.
- Completion of work acknowledgment to instructor for every assignment
- Provide timely, specific and personalized assessments for each assignment.
- Instead of written feedback for each assignment, try using video/audio tracks for giving feedback for assignments. Jing is a simple, free program that can be used to create a narrated screen capture. Using a screen capture video you can "point" to various parts of an assignment and record verbal feedback.
Helpful Web Resources
How to Motivate Online Students This page offers straightforward tips to keep your online students engaged, such as helping a shy student get involved in an online discussion, or to using creative assignments, and offering additional encouragement via email.
How to Motivate Your Students from eLearn Magazine.
This article presents several suggestions for variety within assignments, ways to reach out to students and methods to engage students in roles that appeal to them.
Motivating Students to Participate in Online Discussions (pdf document) This handout from the University of Calgary offers guidelines about setting expectations, giving the students responsibility, and keeping the discussion content relevant with the rest of the course. (has links to other resources)
Alutu (2006) The guidance role of the instructor in the teaching and learning process. Journal of Instructional Psychology, 65, 44-49.
Ames (1992) Classrooms: Goals, structures, and student motivation. Journal of Educational Psychology, 84, 261-271.
Arbaugh (2001) How instructor immediacy behaviors affect student satisfaction and learning in web-based courses. Business Communication Quarterly. 65, 42-54.
Crumpacker (2001) Faculty pedagogical approach, skill, and motivation in today's distance education milieu. Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration 4:4.
Dennis et al. (2007) The little engine that could - How to start the motor? Motivating the online student. Insight2: http://insightjournal.net/?page_id=146
Hutchins (2003) Instructional immediacy and the seven principles: Strategies for facilitating online courses. Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration.
Kerssen-Griep et al. (2003) Sustaining the desire to learn: Dimensions of perceived instructional facework related to student involvement and motivation to learn. Western Journal of Communication, 67, 357-361.
Moore (2006) Collaboration online: Sloan-C Resources. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 10, 81-89.Northup (2002) Online learners' preferences for interaction. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3, 219-226.