Modeling the interior of the Earth using Seismic Waves

Eric M. D. Baer, Dusty Wilson, Tina Ostrander
Author Profile

This activity was selected for the On the Cutting Edge Exemplary Teaching Collection

Resources in this top level collection a) must have scored Exemplary or Very Good in all five review categories, and must also rate as “Exemplary” in at least three of the five categories. The five categories included in the peer review process are

  • Scientific Accuracy
  • Alignment of Learning Goals, Activities, and Assessments
  • Pedagogic Effectiveness
  • Robustness (usability and dependability of all components)
  • Completeness of the ActivitySheet web page

For more information about the peer review process itself, please see http://serc.carleton.edu/NAGTWorkshops/review.html.



This page first made public: Mar 28, 2006

Summary

This is an inquiry-based student exercise designed to explore how we use seismic waves to understand the structure of the Earth's interior. Students test several models of the interior of the Earth beginning with a simple homogeneous Earth and moving toward more complex multi-layered Earth models. First, students test the viability of a homogeneous (one-layer) Earth using observed P-wave arrival times throughout the globe. Subsequently, the practicality of a two-layer model is explored as students graphically determine ray paths and travel times and perform simple calculations of Snell's law. Finally, students are asked use a publicly available Java program to calculate wave travel times through a model of Earth that they create (with as many or as few layers as they see fit). The ultimate goal involves student generation of a model that reproduces actual measured seismic travel times as closely as possible.

Learning Goals

Northridge Earthquake image At the end of this exercise, students should be able to:
  • demonstrate an understanding of reverse modeling (taking measured data and creating a model that produces the measured data)
  • explain how models of the Earth's interior are formulated and tested
  • use mathematical techniques (graphing, calculation) to discover more about the physical world around us.
At the end of this exercise students may be able to:
  • Discuss how modeling might create multiple satisfactory results (non-unique solutions)
  • discuss the process of iteration
  • examine the process of modeling and errors associated with it, and participate in a discussion of acceptable congruence

Context for Use

Interior of the Earth

I use this lab in both an intro-physical geology class and a non-majors seismology class. The students will have to know about seismic waves beforehand, but there is very little other assumed knowledge. The whole project can take 3-4 hours. The first module, which looks at travel times through a homogenous earth, is useful if you want just a 1 hour or less activity to begin the a discussion of how we use seismic waves to tell what the interior of the Earth is like.

Description and Teaching Materials

The output of the JAVA program for a 2 layered Earth
There are several documents you will need for this lab:
  • Pre-lab assignment (Microsoft Word 31kB Feb9 06)
  • The prelab assignment asks students to think about the geometry of the Earth using exercises that require understanding triangle geometry, trigonometric functions (using a calculator), and the relationship of radius to diameter. The prelab is available in two versions: an editable version in MS Word (Microsoft Word 31kB Feb9 06) and as a .pdf (needs Adobe Reader or equivalent) (Acrobat (PDF) 15kB Feb9 06).
    The output of the JAVA program for the PREM which has 74 layers
  • Interior of the Earth Lab (Microsoft Word 121kB Feb9 06) is a word file that is what the students use and fill out. It has full directions. The lab (Acrobat (PDF) 91kB Feb9 06) is also available in .pdf format if you prefer.
  • Scale diagram of the Earth (Acrobat (PDF) 401kB Feb9 06) Students will use this diagram for drawing seismic rays on for the second part of the lab. This will need to be printed on 11 x 17 paper.
Curious how this project came be? Need some diagrams to help explain the concepts? Try this powerpoint presentation (PowerPoint 906kB Feb9 06) and see if it helps.

Teaching Notes and Tips

For the whole activity I generally use 2 2-hour lab periods. However, because the assignment is open ended, students can take significantly longer. The instructor will need to decide how close they want the student results to be to the actual measured velocities or give them a time limit.

Students will need paper, pencil, protractor, ruler, and a calculator with trigonometric functions. They will also need an internet-connected computer with the current version of Java installed for the third part of this activity.

One common problem with this lab is that the Java program won't run. This is because you don't have the most current version of Java. The applet for module 3 does not run in Java 1.4, but does in 1.5

Assessment

I grade the submitted pre-lab and lab.

References and Resources

  • The trigonometry page will be helpful for instructors teaching students trig functions.
  • A good approximation of the "correct" answer is the PREM (Preliminary Reference Earth Model) by Dziewonski and Anderson (1981 - Phys. Earth. Planet. Int., Vol 25, p.297-356).