Initial Publication Date: July 13, 2016
DOI | Cite this

"When you come to a fork in the road, take it."

Caitlin Callahan, Grand Valley State University

I started my graduate studies in geology with the idea that I would ultimately transition into geoscience education after I earned a PhD in a sub-discipline. I was originally introduced to science education as a field of study through my position as an assistant in the Education Department at the American Geosciences Institute, where I worked for three years after college. As part of my duties there, I assisted with a workshop for K-12 curriculum developers from all STEM disciplines. One of the presenters at the meeting was from the AAAS; she mentioned that the AAAS was then offering funding for post-doctoral research positions in science education. The expectation was that candidates would have a PhD in one of the STEM fields but would be interested to transition to the study of learning in the discipline. That PowerPoint slide planted a seed in my mind: I could pursue a PhD in Geoscience and then transition into Geoscience Education.

After AGI, I began to pursue that path. I earned a Masters in Geology. Then I moved on to a PhD program. But multiple problems developed. After three years, I made the difficult decision that I could no longer stay; however, I was not prepared to abandon my academic goals entirely. I started to search for PhD programs in Geoscience Education. I approached the task similar to how I had originally approached searching for graduate programs in geology. I read papers. I found an article in the Journal of Geoscience Education entitled "Research in Science Education: The Expert-Novice Continuum" by Dr. Heather Petcovic and Dr. Julie Libarkin. I was captivated. I had grown up thinking that expertise was mostly about intelligence. The article conveyed that expertise is much more interesting and complex than that. In addition, the article was a powerful example of what was possible in Geoscience Education. My earlier daydreams had been amorphous. I had aspired to Geoscience Education without a concrete topic of interest. The article was a revelation; I now had a starting point. I wanted to gain a better understanding of the nature of geoscience expertise.

I applied and was accepted to the PhD program in Science Education at Western Michigan University to work with with Heather Petcovic. I was going to be a graduate assistant on a research study related to geologic expertise. I was delighted. But I also made a conscious decision regarding my future. I would be starting all over; no credits would transfer. It would mean four more years, at least, of graduate school. Even before friends, family, or professors at my former institution could voice concerns, I promised myself that I would go through with this change without having a clear sense of what my job opportunities would be after I finished. Ever since my time at AGI, I had been aware that the Geoscience Education community had been expanding and developing. I decided that I would begin the PhD at WMU without knowing exactly where it would lead. I would find a way to make a place for myself.

Close

Looking for teaching materials?
Check our quick guide to Finding Earth Education Resources at SERC for some strategies that will help you make the most of the collections.

Remind me later Open the guide in a new tab