|
Starting Point-Teaching Entry Level Geoscience > Peer Review > Examples of Peer Review > Student Peer Review Through A Discussion Board to Develop an Invasive Species Paper
Explore Teaching Examples | Provide Feedback

Student Peer Review Through A Discussion Board to Develop an Invasive Species Paper

Activity based on Examining a Potential Paper Topic from the Northern Illinois University English Department. Assignment modified and Starting Point page by L.A. Guertin, Penn State Delaware County, Earth Science.
Author Profile
This material is replicated on a number of sites as part of the SERC Pedagogic Service Project

Summary

Through computer technology, students develop a paper topic (in this case, invasive species) with the assistance of additional students answering guided questions. The original student must respond to the comments by the fellow classmates. All of the communication is conducted through an electronic discussion board.

Learning Goals

This exercise assists students in developing electronic communication skills through a discussion board. The electronic peer review of the paper topic provides students the opportunity provide constructive feedback. In addition, the topic of invasive species is one that encourages students to connect natural processes and/or human actions with societal values and priorities.

Context for Use

This exercise should be given as an assignment outside of class with technology facilitating the procedure. Students only require access to a computer connected to the internet and a discussion board program (such as ones found in WebCT and Blackboard). The assignment can be given over a one-day or up to a two-week period. The instructor can log in to the discussion board to review the live electronic exchange of comments or final responses.

Teaching Materials

Provide students with the following assignment:
You will be writing a paper on invasive species. You will be choosing one particular invasive specie and documenting its history and impact on science and society, or you may choose a specific region (such as Chesapeake Bay) and discuss the invasives in that ecosystem. Before writing an essay on your invasive species subject, you will further develop your topic with the assistance of two of your peers through an electronic discussion board. Enter the discussion board and answer the following questions (be sure to be as complete as possible so that your peers can do a thorough assessment).
  • What is the concept relating to invasive species you will explain in your paper?
  • Who is your intended reader?
  • What particular aspect of invasive species will you focus on?
  • What will your main point be?
  • How will you make invasive species and your essay understandable and interesting?

Teaching Notes and Tips

Assessment

Assessment is conducted by the students in the discussion board. After the student has answered the questions relating to his/her paper topic, the first peer reviewer enters the same discussion board, reads the answers to the questions, then types responses to a new set of questions. The instructor should remind the peer reviewers that their feedback is to assist the student writer in the appropriateness of the topic and the approach to the topic.
Student Reviewer #1
  • Does this paper topic and approach sound interesting to you? If yes, in what way? If no, explain what isn't interesting about it.
  • Would you care to read more about this topic? If yes, what would you like to find out?
  • What, if anything, do you already know about this invasive species issue?

A second student then conducts a peer review of the same topic of the proposed invasive species paper.
Student Reviewer #2
  • Does this paper topic and approach sound interesting to you? If yes, in what way? If no, explain what isn't interesting about it.
  • Would you care to read more about this topic? If yes, what would you like to find out?
  • What, if anything, do you already know about this invasive species issue?
  • Do you and the first Student Reviewer tend to agree about the topic? Explain the reasons for your agreement or disagreement.
  • Do you think that your response and the response from the other Student Reviewer fairly reflect what most readers will think/feel about this invasive species topic? Explain as best you can.

The original student author of the invasive species paper topic is then required to review the peer comments and respond in the discussion board to the following questions.
Original Student Writer
  • Considering the comments, how confident do you feel writing about this invasive species topic? Explain.
  • Which, if any, of the comments surprised you?
  • Do the comments make you consider a new approach in any way? Explain why.
  • Considering how much your classmates know (or don't know) about the topic, how much explaining will you need to do in your essay?


References and Resources

Original assignment: Examining a Potential Paper Topic from Northern Illinois University's English Department.

Invasive species resources

Invasive Species: The Nation's Invasive Species Information System

Pew Oceans Commission Introduced Species in United States Coastal Waters (more info) (PDF)

The CQ Researcher, October 05, 2001. "Invasive Species - Can Foreign Plants and Animals be Stopped?" v. 11, n. 34, p. 785-816.

Scientific American "Frontiers" episode on Alien Invasion (more info) . The episode can be viewed online with links to resources.


Subject

Biology:Ecology, Environmental Science:Ecosystems:Habitats:Invasive species

Resource Type

Assessments:Peer Assessment, Activities:Writing Assignment

Grade Level

College Lower (13-14):Introductory Level

Ready for Use

Ready to Use

Earth System Topics

Biosphere, :Ecology

Topics

Biosphere, Human Dimensions/Resources

See more Examples of Peer Review »