Exploring Ecosystem Vulnerability
Summary
In this guided in-class tutorial, students explore how species traits, ecological interactions, and environmental pressures interact to shape ecosystem vulnerability. Working with IUCN assessment data for assigned taxa, students evaluate exposure, sensitivity, and adaptive capacity to calculate relative vulnerability scores. They then compare patterns within and between temperate montane and tropical reef ecosystems, identifying key drivers of vulnerability and resilience. Through collaborative analysis and discussion, students develop a deeper understanding of how ecological and environmental factors determine species' responses to change—insights they will later apply to interpreting past ecosystems.
Collapse
Learning Goals
Students will learn how to evaluate species and ecosystem vulnerability by integrating ecological, environmental, and trait-based information. Conceptually, they will understand how exposure, sensitivity, and adaptive capacity interact to determine vulnerability and how these factors differ across ecosystems. The activity develops higher-order thinking skills including critical analysis, data interpretation, and synthesis of complex biological and environmental relationships. Students practice collaborative discussion, comparative reasoning, and communicating scientific findings through both small-group and whole-class discussions.
Context for Use
This lecture tutorial is designed for undergraduate courses in earth history, environmental geoscience, historical geology, or paleontology. It works well in classes of any size, provided students can work in small groups (3–4 students). The activity fits within a single class period (approximately 50–75 minutes) and is best used after students have been introduced to concepts of species traits, ecological interactions, and vulnerability frameworks (e.g., exposure, sensitivity, adaptive capacity). No special equipment is required beyond access to IUCN species assessments (attached below; freely available and easily accessible on IUCNredlist.org) and printed worksheets. The activity is easily adapted to different ecosystems or taxa depending on course focus and available data. It serves effectively as a bridge between modern ecological concepts and subsequent applications to paleoecological or deep-time case studies, reinforcing the concept of uniformitarianism.
Description and Teaching Materials
Attached materials include: (1) the student-facing worksheet, (2) a pdf compilation of 12 IUCN species assessments (6 tropical marine, 6 temperate montane), and (3) a powerpoint lecture on vulnerability
Vulnerability Worksheet.docx (Microsoft Word 2007 (.docx) 23kB Oct29 25)
All_IUCN_Summaries.pdf (Acrobat (PDF) 13MB Oct29 25)
Vulnerability_ClimateChange.pptx (PowerPoint 2007 (.pptx) 15.8MB Oct29 25)
Teaching Notes and Tips
Before starting the activity, briefly review the concepts of exposure, sensitivity, and adaptive capacity, emphasizing how these components interact to determine overall vulnerability. Students often conflate exposure (external pressures) with sensitivity (intrinsic traits), so it helps to model one example together as a class using a familiar species. Encourage students to make informed inferences when data are incomplete—this promotes critical thinking about uncertainty in conservation assessments.
During the activity, circulate among groups to prompt deeper discussion about the ecological or trait-based mechanisms behind their rankings rather than focusing solely on numeric scores. When groups compare ecosystems, guide them to recognize how different environmental contexts shape vulnerability patterns and to identify cross-cutting drivers such as climate change or habitat fragmentation.
For the final discussion, connect student observations to broader course themes, such as ecosystem resilience, extinction risk, or the application of modern frameworks to the fossil record. The activity runs smoothly when each group works from pre-assigned taxa and has quick access to IUCN reports. It can be easily adapted by substituting taxa, ecosystems, or databases relevant to local or thematic course goals.
Assessment
Student understanding is primarily assessed through in-class discussions and group synthesis. During the activity, instructors can gauge comprehension by listening to group reasoning and by prompting students to justify their vulnerability rankings using evidence from traits and ecological context. Whole-class comparisons between ecosystems provide an opportunity to evaluate students' ability to synthesize patterns and articulate broader principles of vulnerability and resilience. Although this activity is not graded summatively on its own, concepts and frameworks developed here are later reinforced through exam questions that ask students to apply the exposure–sensitivity–adaptive capacity model to new taxa or past ecosystems. Instructors may also collect completed worksheets to provide brief formative feedback or check for conceptual consistency across groups.