Mining Decisions: Developing New Perspectives on Mineral Extraction
This activity was selected for the On the Cutting Edge Exemplary Teaching Collection
Resources in this top level collection a) must have scored Exemplary or Very Good in all five review categories, and must also rate as “Exemplary” in at least three of the five categories. The five categories included in the peer review process are
- Scientific Accuracy
- Alignment of Learning Goals, Activities, and Assessments
- Pedagogic Effectiveness
- Robustness (usability and dependability of all components)
- Completeness of the ActivitySheet web page
For more information about the peer review process itself, please see http://serc.carleton.edu/NAGTWorkshops/review.html.
This page first made public: Oct 9, 2012
Learning goals include:
- understanding the economic, social and ecological value of resources;
- realizing the role of a community in land use decisions;
- understanding tradeoffs in local versus global sourcing;
- mapping the complete life cycle of various mineral resources; and
- recognizing the historical context of resource extraction.
Context for Use
Description and Teaching Materials
This activity includes:
Lecture: A lecture is provided before watching and reflecting on the documentary film Red Gold to explain the various perspectives on mining. Red Gold highlights the community struggle for and against a large copper, gold, and molybdenum mine at the headwaters of a prime sockeye salmon run in Alaska. The film highlights the perspectives of the mining company as well as the local commercial fishermen, sport fishermen, and subsistence fishermen. The lecture portion of the activity provides an explanation of the life cycle of salmon and the type of habitat they require. The lecture also highlights the current federal regulations in the United States for air and water quality as well as hazardous waste storage - all issues with large mining activities. The lecture also provides information on foreign copper mining activities, where no such environmental regulations, fair land acquisitions, or worker-rights exist.
Film: The film Red Gold is a 50 minute documentary highlighting the different viewpoints on the proposal for a copper mine (Pebble Mine) near Bristol Bay, Alaska. The film provides both viewpoints but is biased in favor of not proceeding with the mine.
Advertisements: Two advertisements can also be shown to help explain the pro-mining argument. One is from the nonprofit, Truth about Pebble, explaining what the project is and this organization's commitment to environmental protection. The other, from the Pebble Partnership, provides some propaganda for the coexistence of miners and fishermen in the same area (http://www.pebblepartnership.com/multimedia).
Scientific article: Many studies explore the relationship between mining wastes and impacts on fish. One such study explains the potential direct and indirect impacts of this particular copper mine. The study provides much needed background information on the habitat alteration proposed by the mine. In addition, the study discusses other mines and their failure to maintain water quality in surrounding watersheds. ("Potential Impacts of the Proposed Pebble Mine on Fish Habitat and Fishery Resources of Bristol Bay," William J. Hauser Fish Talk, Consulting September, 2007)
Reflection: After watching the film and advertisements, reading the article, and hearing the lecture, students are asked to write a reflection for the next class period. They are provided with additional background information, such as this bay being opened to oil drilling, the amount of money to be paid to Alaskans from the copper mine, etc., to prompt their responses. Students are asked to write between 1-2 pages in response to the following questions:
1. Do you think the mine should be allowed to open?
2. Do you think that certain voices in the Pebble Mine argument have more weight than others?
Discussion: In the following class, students meet in small groups for 20-30 minutes to discuss their reflection.
(Optional) Project: After these activities, students are assigned to research the life cycle of one mineral from a select list of minerals. This has been appropriate for an Environmental Geology class but could be modified for other classes as well. Students write a 3-4 page research paper on how their chosen mineral is mined, manufactured, consumed, and disposed of or recycled/reused. They are encouraged to include the perspectives, both local and foreign, on the environmental impact of these mines. They are also encouraged to consider when and where those minerals were mined in the United States and how much is now imported from abroad. They should consider if those minerals are arriving from countries with few environmental regulations or worker rights.
Presentations: Students present their research on mineral life cycles to groups of 4-5 other students and they are graded by their peers. Students are encouraged to bring up the sustainability aspects of mineral extraction and the ethical dilemma of "our environment or theirs."
References and Resources
Paper: Potential Impacts of the Proposed Pebble Mine on Fish Habitat and Fishery Resources of Bristol Bay, William J. Hauser Fish Talk, Consulting September, 2007, available on the web at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/255631845_Potential_Impacts_of_the_Proposed_Pebble_Mine_on_Fish_Habitat_and_Fishery_Resources_of_Bristol_Bay
Website: Injury Trends in Mining, United States Department of Labor, Mine Safety and Health Administration, http://www.msha.gov/mshainfo/factsheets/mshafct2.htm
Film: Red Gold, Felt Soul Media, 2008, https://vimeo.com/ondemand/11980. A 50 minute documentary showing various perspectives on the Pebble Mine project.
Bristol Bay Alliance, http://www.bristolbayalliance.com/. The Bristol Bay Alliance is a "group of fishermen, business owners and local citizens working to help ensure that the people who live, work, and play in the Bristol Bay region have the most influential voice of any group regarding the future of our land and waters." The website provides mining facts, links and several documents (including maps) about the negative impacts of irresponsible mines on the environment.
Save Bristol Bay, http://www.savebristolbay.org/home. Pebble Mine Alaska is a website that "contains a quick breakdown of what is being proposed to the people, some alternative that should be considered, an active forum and a huge volume of information about protecting Bristol Bay from any conceivable future disasters from the mining operations."
Pebble Limited Partnership, http://www.pebblepartnership.com/. The site provides information on the state of the mine and information about the project, a joint venture between Anglo American and Northern Dynasty.
Truth About Pebble, link no longer working. Truth About Pebble is a "nonprofit citizens' organization that supports the proposed Pebble Project in Southwest Alaska."
Mines and Communities, http://www.minesandcommunities.org/list.php?f=9. This website contains stories and news headlines from around to the world in order to "expose the social, economic, and environmental impacts of mining, particularly as they affect Indigenous and land-based peoples. Global in scope, the site was set up in 2001 by organizations and individuals from seven different countries who met in London to demand far greater accountability and transparency on the part of the minerals' industry." It is useful for making the argument for mining locally, despite the environmental costs. Washington
Department of Ecology, The Salmon Life Cycle, http://www.ecy.wa.gov/programs/sea/pugetsound/species/salmon_cyc.html. This website demonstrates the habitat needs of salmon throughout their life cycle.
Pebble Mine Project Map, Pebble Partnership, http://www.pebblepartnership.com/documents/regional-map.