Find, Measure, and Model a Pendulum!
Summary
Students are generally exposed to pendulum motion in fundamental physics classes, as early as their first year. In a higher level course, such as Vibrations, students will learn how to derive the equation of motion and the following assumptions, such as small angle approximations.
In this activity, students will be asked to look for a simple pendulum from their daily lives (such as keys jingling from a string, bag of groceries, etc.), take measurements (small angle vs large angle) to find its frequency, and compare the measured frequency to the linearized and non-linearized equations learned from ME350 (Vibrations 1 with Applications). The students will then plot the measured vs predicted data on MATLAB over some time, and analyze why there are discrepancies between values.
Learning Goals
The overall learning goal of the activity is:
Students will be able to identify and model a real-life pendulum and compare measurements, linearized, and non-linearized equations of motion through visualization on MATLAB, and recognize that theory often relies on assumptions and simplifications that might not hold true in real-life scenarios.
Specifically,
Higher-Order Thinking Skills (1)
- Model Development (a): Students will be able to recognize a real-life scenario as a pendulum, define the corresponding "mass" and "length" of the pendulum.
- "Field" Measurements (b): Students will be able to take measurements of both the "small angle" and "large angle" behavior of the said pendulum by measuring the period of the system, being mindful of the corresponding errors and uncertainties.
- Data Analysis (c): Students will be able to analyze the measured data by using the relationship between period and frequency, and compare the measurements with that of the linearized and non-linearized differential equations of motion for a pendulum.
- Critical Thinking (d): Students will be able to recognize that there are discrepancies between phenomena in real-life and theoretical equations as some of the theories we learn in class rely on assumptions and simplifications. Students will also be able to recognize which of the measurements correspond to which versions of the equations of motion.
Programming (2)
- (a) Students will apply MATLAB to computationally find a solution for the two types of equations of motion, linearized and non-linearized.
- (b) Students will be able to visualize, plot, and compare the different behaviors of the model (small-angle & large-angle measurements, linearized & non-linearized equations of motion). Students will also learn "good practices" for plots, such as necessary parts of the plot, font sizes, color. etc. to ensure effective communication of the data.
- (c) Students will be able to sufficiently document what their MATLAB program is doing, through comments, subsections, and mindful variable names.
Writing (3)
- Students will learn effective communication skills to relay the model, procedures, program, results, and the discussion related to the activity.
Context for Use
This activity could easily be done as part of class, or as a take-home project like I had implemented. The time it takes to do the activity depends on the student and which pendulum they decide to model and measure. I implemented this in ME350, which is a junior level class that is required for students in mechanical, aerospace, acoustical, and robotics engineering, and is often taken by students getting a mechanical engineering minor.
Students should be familiar with plotting sine waves, solving differential equations, and plotting behavior over time. Students should know how to write reports and explain their findings. Students should be able to take measurements of the period of the pendulum, and calculate the natural frequency.
The activity as implemented is a take-home project. For reference, I have it named so that it's a take-home "quiz," and it is worth double the amount of points of a typical quiz that can help improve the students' overall quiz score to encourage students to put in more effort. However, this activity can be easily modified to either be a simple in-class exercise, a lab, or a multi-day lab. I am also interested in implementing MATLAB LiveScripts to make it more interactive for potentially younger students as well.
Description and Teaching Materials
The only document I provide to the students specifically for this activity is the student_handout_project_word.docx (Microsoft Word 2007 (.docx) 982kB Oct27 26) (word document for easy editing). The handout includes the following:
- overview of the project
- description of the project scope and procedures
- detailed list of requirements for the report the students will have to submit
- guidelines for plots and an example of a "good" plot
Students will be asked to submit a .pdf of the written report, .xlsx of their measurements, and .m of their MATLAB file(s). In my first iteration, I had not implemented the distinction between small angle and large angle measurements. You can see the initial version of the student handout here: student_handout_project_v1.pdf (Acrobat (PDF) 287kB Oct26 26). With this in mind, here is an example submission from a student: student_submission_example.pdf (Acrobat (PDF) 4.3MB Oct26 26). Again, I named it a "quiz" to motivate students to put in more effort to help increase their quiz grade category — but the activity described here is a project, not actually a quiz.
Sample MATLAB program for educators ONLY:
Teaching Notes and Tips
Pendulum motion is often taught as early as in first-year physics courses, and thus the activity could be modified to include just the simple pendulum equations, rather than the non-linearized motion. The focus for that implementation could be on measurement uncertainties and human error, rather than the discussion of small angle approximations. The specific activity as implemented is for an upper level Mechanical Vibrations course, which, at our institution, has Differential Equations, Mechanics of Materials, and Dynamics as prerequisites. To implement the activity as provided, students should understand the limitations and assumptions of the simple pendulum equation of motion, and know both the linearized and non-linearized equations of motion. Students should know how to solve for ODEs on MATLAB, or at least be able to look at references given to them and utilize the help page for ODEs and modify equations into the function format. Students should also be comfortable plotting multiple data series on a single plot, making sure that the plot is visually pleasing and has all necessary information to be understood by others. I personally implement this activity towards the end to motivate students and to help them increase their overall grade, but the activity can be implemented towards the beginning of a vibrations course as long as the pendulum and the governing equations have been covered. The activity is also implemented as a take-home, individual activity as designed, but could be easily modified as an in-class activity with select students showcasing their real-life pendulum and the class taking measurements together.
In this activity, students will explore the following topics:
- What makes a system a pendulum? How does pendulum motion connect to other types of sinusoidal motion learned in different classes and backgrounds?
- Mechanical/Aerospace: any simple harmonic motion, sinusoidal motion, mechanical vibration
- Acoustical: sound, frequency, pitch, and other types of vibration
- Electrical/Robotics: circuits, specifically RLC (resistor, inductor, capacitor) circuits
- Biomedical: biomechanics, vibrations of the body
- Math: eigenvalues, eigenvectors
- What is the difference between the linearized and non-linearized motion behavior? What is the underlying assumption? How do you define small vs large angles for a pendulum?
- Why might measured values and linearized/non-linearized motion still deviate from one another? What other dissipative forces, such as air resistance, might exist? What type of errors might attribute to the measured values?
Assessment
The students are evaluated based on their reports, specifically if they include all parts necessary for the submission outlined in the handout. The required parts of the submission outlined are:
- a short report [3] with:
- picture of their "pendulum" [1a]
- Identification/definition of the "concept" of the pendulum and what it is that they are measuring[1a]
- a free-body diagram (FBD) along with their picture of the pendulum [1a]
- defined variables, including the two angles used for measurements [1a, 1b]
- equation(s) used to find the natural frequency of both measurements, along with the linearized and non-linearized equations of motion [1c]
- a screenshot of the Excel file(s) [1b]
- measured frequencies vs calculated frequencies, making sure to identify how the four behaviors (small angle, large angle, linearized, non-linearized) were paired for comparisons [1c, 1d]
- plot(s) from MATLAB program, specifically at least two plots, comparing the measurement-equation result pairs (small angle, large angle, linearized, non-linearized) [2b]
- check to ensure that students have at least two plots, and that they correctly paired small-angle measurements with linearized, and large-angle measurements with non-linearized motion
- the two plots should also be "clear enough that they can be standalone with just a figure caption"
- discussion of the results and justifications for potential discrepancies or other findings [1d]
- some keywords to look for were "small angle approximation," "1D motion," and "air resistance" as potential factors causing discrepancies between real-life phenomena and equations
- Excel file with measurements (for both small angle & large angle conditions) [1b]
- 10 separate measurements of at least 5 full cycles
- measured periods and calculated natural frequencies
- averaged periods and frequencies
- MATLAB program [2] including the measured values, equations of motion, and plots
- the program should run on its own, and the instructor should check that the MATLAB program provided gives the same results and plots submitted in the student report
* specific learning outcomes in []
References and Resources
Pendulum Equations of Motion:
- Inman, Daniel J. Engineering Vibration. 3rd ed., Pearson Prentice Hall, 2007.
- Thomson, William T., and Marie Dillon Dahleh. Theory of Vibration with Applications. 5th ed., Prentice Hall, 1997.
MATLAB Resources for Students:
- Example of a pendulum and plotting: https://www.mathworks.com/help/symbolic/simulate-physics-pendulum-swing.html
- ODE documentation on MATLAB: https://www.mathworks.com/help/matlab/ref/ode45.html