Develop Students' Science Identity
--- Schinske et al., 2016
Every individual encompasses multiple identities. When students are considering their future careers and educational pathways, one of the factors involved in their decisions is whether or not they can align their perception of a career with one or more of their personal identities. If they cannot see "someone like them" (whatever that means to them) doing a job, it is less likely that they will follow that particular path (Margolis and Fisher, 1997). Indeed, having a strong science identity is one of the only good predictors of moving into a science-related career field after graduation (Stets et al., 2017).
Studies have shown this to be a significant factor in the lack of diversity in STEM fields (Carlone and Johnson, 2007; Hurtado et al., 2009; Zahra et al., 2013). Even though some progress has been made in recent decades, these fields continue to be dominated by white, cis-gendered males which can make it hard for other kinds of students (people of color, women, gender-nonconforming, etc.) to see a place for themselves in STEM. In addition, many students do not come from families or communities where they were exposed to role models from the sciences.
Faculty can help students develop a Science Identity by showcasing examples of scientists who do not fit common stereotypes, helping students see scientists as whole people they can relate to, giving students opportunities to practice doing and talking about science, and highlighting content topics that are relevant to students' lives.
Strategies to Promote Science Identity Development
Example Scientist Spotlight
Resources you could use:
- Her web page at the University of Arizona that shows her accomplishments and has links to her work: http://swes.cals.arizona.edu/people/faculty/karletta-chief
- One of her links is to the American Indian Science and Education Society: http://arizonaaises.weekbly.com/index.html
- A 2.5 minute video about the pathway of her career and her community involvement: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TxfhVV9YfEo
- She co-authored guidelines for considering traditional knowledge in climate change initiatives: http://climatetkw.wordpress.com/guidelines/
Showcase Nonstereotypical Scientists
A powerful way to help students see a place for themselves in STEM is to feature scientists who, collectively, present diverse examples of who scientists are and how science is done (Schinske et al., 2016). Explicitly show diversity in your teaching. Use a diversity of people in the images included in presentations. Showcase the work of non-white geoscientists when appropriate in your courses. Use both historical and modern day examples of diverse individuals. Beyond visual diversity, also include descriptions of scientists as people. Their interests outside of science and pathways they took to where they are (particularly if part of that pathway included time at 2YC) can show students that people in STEM are much more than one-dimensional characters they are often portrayed as.
Schinske et al (2016) discuss the use of Scientist Spotlights as a tool for increasing students' ability to relate to scientists. This activity pairs profiles of diverse examples of scientists with relevant content areas covered in a class distributed throughout the length of the course. For each homework assignment, students read an article about the scientist's research and a resource about the scientist's personal history. Their study concluded that this activity generated shifts in students' stereotypes of scientists and scientist relatability. Students began to be able to see "scientist" as a possible part of their self concept because they were able to understand real scientists as complex people interested in many things.
- Counter-stereotypical Geoscientist Career Profiles (PowerPoint 2007 (.pptx) 1014kB Oct24 18) developed by Jan Hodder, Oregon Institute of Marine Biology, University of Oregon, for the SAGE 2YC project
- SAGE Musings: Geoscientist Biographical Sketches: How can we help our students - especially those whose parents aren't geoscientists - imagine themselves as future geoscientists?
- Additional Career Profiles of Geoscientists from the SAGE 2YC collection
- Scientist Spotlights is a collection of spotlights and other information by Jeff Schinske, the inventor of scientist sopotlights. You will find profiles, implementation tips and a way to submit your own spotlights.
- transverse RANGES: transverse RANGES (tR) publishes original, long form interview-format articles about individual geoscientists in all geoscience disciplines. tR is motivated to illuminate themes that connect us, celebrate our diversity, and shape the way we look at ourselves as a collective group of scientists.
- Diverse Geologists: Diverse Geologists is an international, collaborative vision to see greater representation of marginalized individuals in geoscience.
- SACNAS Biography Project: an online archive of first-person stories by and about Chicano/Hispanic and Native American scientists with advanced degrees in science.
- Time Scavengers' "Meet the Scientists": Stories of geoscientists, what type of data they use, why they enjoy science, and their advice for young future scientists.
- Kappel, E.S. (Ed) Women in Oceanography - A decade later. Oceanography 2014 Vol 27 no.4 supplement
This special issue of Oceanography illuminates both the progress that has been made over the last decade in addressing career barriers and areas where further attention might still be needed.
- This is What a Scientist Looks Like is a project developed by freelance science writer Allie Wilkinson to challenge the stereotypical perception of a scientist.
- Secret Lives of Scientists and Engineers is an Emmy-nominated web series and site from PBS's NOVA. This is where you can learn about cutting-edge science and engineering, the amazing people who do that work, and the things they do when their lab coats come off â€" win beauty pageants, wrestle professionally, become rock stars and magicians, etc.
- Black History Month: Making History in the Geosciences is a blog post about four extraordinary Black geoscientists.
- Queer Voices in Paleontology is Riley Black's personal account of the challenges of being transgender and non-binary in a discipline with an 'Indiana Jones' image.
- STEM Role Models Posters is exactly what it sounds like -- a set of downloadable posters about a diverse group of STEM professionals.
- Story Collider is a podcast about those who do science: https://www.storycollider.org/
- 500 Queer Scientists: https://500queerscientists.com/
- University of Illinois Chicago, Career profile videos of alumna of Earth and Environmental Sciences https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMiMl0k06BG0tUtZTt4cWH8hsDDeP_ESD
- Blog on women in geoscience: https://earthsciencesociety.com/category/women-in-geoscience/
- https://www.rachelignotofskydesign.com/women-in-science Has profiles of women scientists.
- https://www.livescience.com/amazing-black-scientists.html and https://cen.acs.org/people/profiles/Six-black-chemists-should-know/97/web/2019/02 have profiles of black scientists
- Native American Scientists:https://woc.aises.org/aises-people
- Scientist with Disabilities: https://royalsociety.org/topics-policy/diversity-in-science/scientists-with-disabilities/
- Charlie Barrows of Cascadia College and the University of Washington has created a list of more than 100 diverse scientists in this google with basic biographical information. sheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1EqlBTHW3mbD-dv92qEJ9Q6upGwLk0WLXU3Zg1cs25U4/edit?usp=sharing . It allows you to sort by many things including field, sex, etc.
Conducting the practices of science - authentic opportunities to use the appropriate tools (and not just physical ones), pose and research their own hypotheses, and become comfortable using the language of science - is an important part of developing a science identity (Seymour et al., 2004; Hurtado et al., 2009). Carlone and Johnson (2007) call this Science Identity Performance and it reinforces the concept that students can be scientists because they can do the tasks involved. Explicitly telling them that "this is what a scientist does" can help them see themselves as scientists.
There are many ways and levels of engaging students in the act of science. From highly-scaffolded inquiry activities where students can gain proficiency with methods and procedures to open-ended, student-led research projects there are multiple ways to incorporate these experiences into courses and programs. Any activity in a course that mimics what scientists do can be used to "remind" students that they are doing science. Lab activities, field trips, even short in-class activities that involve building skills or habits of mind can reinforce students' identity as a scientist.
- SAGE 2YC: Engage 2YC Students in Research - Early exposure to research experiences has been shown to be effective in increased recruitment of students, improved retention and persistence in degree programs, motivation for students to learn and increase self-efficacy, improved attitudes and values about science, and overall increased student success.
- Starting Point: Undergraduate Research - In an undergraduate research experience, students collaborate with faculty on actual research projects, learning about both a particular topic in a field and the research process in general.
- CUREnet - Course-based Undergraduate Research Experiences (CUREs) can be a valuable way to provide research experiences to large numbers of students who otherwise would not have the opportunity.
- SAGE 2YC: What do Geoscientists Do? - If there is a job out there with inputs from or effects on Earth or the environment, then there is a geoscientist somewhere filling that role. Understanding the many career opportunities can help students see themselves as practicing for their future.
Connect core topical concepts to the students' everyday lives. Real-world examples can show how geoscience is relevant to their families and communities because it can address issues they care about. This kind of work transforms abstract classroom materials into concrete actions that students can relate to. Service Learning is a great example of a way to get students out into the community putting their learning into practice.
Incorporating topics that students can relate to, no matter what their major is (where does their electricity come from, how much water does their family use, how was their food produced, etc.) can help students make the connections between what they learn in the classroom with their personal life. The Lifestyle Project is a great way to build students' self-awareness with regard to consumption and sustainability and to move students to action at the personal level.
Give students opportunities to dig into something of interest to them. There is usually a geoscience angle to explore that relates to an interest a student has. You can either leave the topic open or provide a set of topics that students can choose from.
- Oceanside Chats (Acrobat (PDF) 90kB May24 18) activity - Becca Walker, Mt. San Antonio College
Point out relevant stories in the news. There is always some way to tie geoscience in to current events and news, whether it is an event like an earthquake or hurricane, a long term risk like climate change, or how to obtain important mineral resources needed for modern technology.
- Current Events teaching activities from Teach the Earth.
- InTeGrate: Connect to the World We Live In - Building connections between academic learning and examples, experiences, and issues from beyond the ivory tower can increase students interest in a topic and help them transfer this learning to real life situations in their professional and personal lives.
- InTeGrate: Connect Justice to Sustainability - Incorporating topics such as risk and resilience in the face of hazards and geoethics provides a unique lens on incorporating environmental justice and the sociological aspects of sustainability into the classroom.
Callahan, C.N., LaDue, N.D., Baber, L.D., Sexton, J. van der Hoeven Kraft, K.J., and Zamani-Gallaher, E.M. (2017). Theoretical Perspectives on Increasing Recruitment and Retention of Underrepresented Students in the Geosciences. Journal of Geoscience Education, 65(4), 563â€"576.
Carlone, H. B., & Johnson, A. (2007). Understanding the science experiences of successful women of color. Science Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 44(8), 1187â€"1218.
Flowers III, A.M. and Banda, R. (2016). Cultivating science identity through sources of self-efficacy. Journal for Multicultural Education 10 (3) 405-417. DOI 10.1108/JME-01-2016-001.
Hazari, Z., Sadler, P.M., and Sonnert, G. (2013). The Science Identity of College Students: Exploring the Intersection of Gender, Race, and Ethnicity Journal of College Science Teaching. 42(5):82-91
Hurtado, Cabrera, Lin, Arellano, and Espinosa (2009). Diversifying Science: Underrepresented Student Experiences in Structured Research Programs. Research in Higher Education 50(2), 189-214.
Margolis, J., and Fisher, A. (1997). Geek mythology and attracting undergraduate women to computer science. Impacting Change Through Collaboration. Carnegie Mellon University, School of Computer Science, Pittsburgh: Joint National Conference of the Women in Engineering Program Advocates Network and the National Association of Minority Engineering Program Administrators.
Pelch, M.A. and McConnell, D.A. (2017). How Does Adding an Emphasis on Socioscientific Issues Influence Student Attitudes About Science, Its Relevance, and Their Interpretations of Sustainability?. Journal of Geoscience Education, 65(2), 203â€"214.
Rodriguez, S.L., Cunningham, K., and Jordan, A. (2016). What a Scientist Looks Like: How Community Colleges Can Utilize and Enhance Science Identity Development as a Means to Improve Success for Women of Color, Community College Journal of Research and Practice. DOI: 10.1080/10668926.2016.1251354
Schinske J., Perkins, H., Snyder, A., and Wyer, M. (2016). Scientist Spotlight Homework Assignments Shift Students' Stereotypes of Scientists and Enhance Science Identity in a Diverse Introductory Science Class. CBE - Life Sciences Education 15 (3)
Seymour, Hunter, Laursen, and Deantoni (2004). Establishing the Benefits of Research Experiences for Undergraduates in the Sciences: First Findings from a Three-Year Study. Science Education 88(4), 493.
Shin, J.E.L., Levy, S.R., London, B (2016). Effects of role model exposure on STEM and non-STEM student engagement. Journal of Applied Social Psychology. 46, 410â€"427
Stets, J.E., Brenner P.S., Burke, P.J., and Serpe, R.T. (2017). The science identity and entering a science occupation. Social Science Research, 64(1), 1-14. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2016.10.016
Zahra Hazari, Philip M. Sadler and Gerhard Sonnert. 2013. The Science Identity of College Students: Exploring the Intersection of Gender, Race, and Ethnicity. Journal of College Science Teaching. 42(5):82-91