Interdisciplinary Problem-Solving Project for the Science Classroom
This page is authored by Liliana Caughman from Northwest Indian College - Nisqually Campus, and the Evergreen State College.
This activity was selected for the On the Cutting Edge Reviewed Teaching Collection
This activity has received positive reviews in a peer review process involving five review categories. The five categories included in the process are
- Scientific Accuracy
- Alignment of Learning Goals, Activities, and Assessments
- Pedagogic Effectiveness
- Robustness (usability and dependability of all components)
- Completeness of the ActivitySheet web page
For more information about the peer review process itself, please see https://serc.carleton.edu/teachearth/activity_review.html.
- First Publication: July 19, 2017
- Reviewed: December 10, 2020 -- Reviewed by the On the Cutting Edge Activity Review Process
Summary
For a final project in an introductory course on science and sustainability, the class chooses an interdisciplinary, local, and culturally relevant science and sustainability problem. Each student is assigned (or chooses) a special role i.e. The Fisheries Biologist or The Social Scientist, etc. The students each write up a report (that utilizes material we have learned in class as well as individual research) that aims to examine the problem and suggest mitigation strategies from the perspective of their individual roles. Additionally, each student creates a 1-page flyer that condenses their research and ideas and presents it in a compelling way. Then, as a class, the students share their work and come to an ultimate decision on what could or should be done to address or mitigate the problem. They present their position to a special council (composed of 2-3 educators) who question each "expert" and ultimately help to evaluate the students' work.
Topics
Human/Cultural,
Geography,
Oceanography,
Soils,
Geoscience,
Soils and Agriculture,
Sustainability,
Ecosystems,
Environmental Ethics/Values,
Environmental Science,
Sociology,
Political Science,
English,
Anthropology Grade Level
College Lower (13-14), College Upper (15-16), Graduate/Professional
Diversity, Equity, Inclusion and Justice
Public Policy and STEM: STEM disciplines can strengthen data-based decision making in the public sphere.
Environmental Justice: Environmental burdens and benefits should be shared equitably between all communities.
Ethics: All students deserve guidance on how to move through their environment, community, and discipline in an ethical manner.
Follow the links above to find more resources from
Teach the Earth on a specific topic.
Share your modifications and improvements to this activity through the Community Contribution Tool »
Learning Goals
The goal of this activity is for students, working individually and as a group, to utilize knowledge from the course, research, and communication skills to suggest solutions or strategies to address a complex problem. This involves critical thinking; written, visual, and oral presentation of material; sharing ideas with peers; and collaborating to find a workable solution. The activity should motivate students to become more interested in sustainability problem-solving because they can explore their individual role/responsibility and because a chosen problem ideally should be connected to their sense of place.
Context for Use
This project is typically used as a longer term and cumulative final project. I used it successfully in my introductory level undergraduate science courses at a Tribal college in Washington State. I found that it worked well in my small classes where assigning an individually-created role for each student was possible. However, I can imagine that, with only a few minor tweaks, it could easily be scaled up for larger classes and more advanced levels. Usually students need about 3 weeks from the time the project is assigned until the time that it is due. I typically gave my students a little class time here and there to talk about it with their group members, but it is mostly an individual project. I used this assignment in my science courses, but this approach could be applicable in any discipline that explores multi-faceted, interdisciplinary issues.
Description and Teaching Materials
The attached file offers an example of how to set up this project. In the example, the topic concerns industrial hemp production because that is what the class chose to study; their local tribe was actually exploring this option when I taught this class. This particular problem could be easily be swapped out for a problem more relevant to your class but I suggest allowing the students to come up with the problem themselves. You will see a description of the different prompts for different students depending on their role. I picked these specifically based on the interests of my students and they can be tailored to match the needs of your class.
Interdisciplinary Problem Solving Project Example (Microsoft Word 2007 (.docx) 18kB Jul19 17)Teaching Notes and Tips
Students will definitely need additional handouts with an example of the type of flyer they need to create, and grading rubrics for the writing assignment and the final presentation. These have not been included because stipulations vary wildly from class to class and the skill level of the students.
I discovered that the students' presentation to a council or external panel was critically important because it motivated students to show their best work and mimicked what happens in the real world. At Northwest Indian College where I teach, our panel was called a "Tribal Council," because that is the form of local government most relevant to the students who live on the reservation.
Assessment
At the conclusion of the final presentation to the "tribal council" I ask the students to write a short reflection about their time working on this project individually as well as while working to come to a consensus as a team with regard to possible solutions or alternative strategies to address the problem. This offers the best way to assess the project collectively. As for grading, I graded students individually on the quality of their written paper and 1-page flyer (typically looking at how well they argued for strategies to address the problem from the perspective of their role utilizing relevant research, class material, and critical thinking). I graded the group collectively on their communication between each other and to the "tribal council" during the final presentation (this assesses the important group communication and problem-solving aspect of the project and also serves to be sure everyone in the group speaks and no one person dominates the conversation).
References and Resources