Module 7: Induced River Infiltration to Wells G & H
Module Goal:
- Understand the difficulties associated with measuring river infiltration into groundwater.
- Learn how groundwater pumping can cause surface water to infiltrate into an aquifer.
- Review how the expert witnesses addressed induced infiltration from the Aberjona River to wells G and H and its impact the quality of water pumped by these wells into the municipal water system.
Student Assignment
Overview
The plaintiffs expert hydrogeologist, Dr. George Pinder, created a controversy in the courtroom when he described how the Aberjona River interacted with wells G and H when the wells were pumped. The controversy concerned his opinion of the amount of surface water that infiltrated from the Aberjona River into the aquifer that was captured by wells G and H. Excerpts of the testimony (see copies) document the importance of assessing this aspect of the hydrogeologic system at wells G and H. The ambiguity of Dr. Pinder's testimony was identified by several jurors as their reason for skepticism of being able to conclusively identify the source and contribution of contaminants to the wells.
Understanding the effect of induced infiltration to aquifers
Understanding how induced infiltration of surface water has to be considered as part of the value waiting either geologic budgets is an important aspect of understanding the sustainability of the resource. This topic is addressed in the USGS Circular 1186. Pages 30 through 35 illustrate how groundwater flow can converge toward a stream (gaining stream -- the stream gains flow from groundwater discharge into it) and how groundwater flow can diverge away from a streambed (losing stream -- the stream loses water by infiltration to the groundwater system) and contribute water to an aquifer. Knowing the locations of gaining and losing stream reaches and quantifying the amounts of iinfiltration and discharge are important to computing hydrologic budgets and determining the sustainability of the resource, as described in the section on groundwater budgets.Profile of the Aberjona River Valley
The geologic data presented in Module 3, which is taken from court records can be used to construct a geologic cross section of the Aberjona River Valley. One of the interpretations based on creating a cross section is consideration of the effects of interbedded peat and fine sands that underlie the river valley. In preparing for a mock trial, a critical question that needs to be considered is the effect of these materials on induced infiltration from the Aberjona River to wells G and H.
More Information
Data Sources
Newspaper Articles
- Data shows wells may draw river water (Acrobat (PDF) 37kB Jul3 06), 14 May 1986
Dan Kennedy, Daily Times Chronicle - Judge Skinner questions credibility of witness (Acrobat (PDF) 53kB Jul3 06), 15 May 1986
Dan Kennedy, Daily Times Chronicle - 1978 report said aquifer draws from Aberjona River (Acrobat (PDF) 46kB Jul3 06), 16 May 1986
Dan Kennedy, Daily Times Chronicle - A difficult week for plaintiffs' scientist in toxic trial (Acrobat (PDF) 33kB Jul3 06), 19 May 1986
Dan Kennedy, Daily Times Chronicle - Chemical findings are inconsistent (Acrobat (PDF) 47kB Jul3 06), 21 May 1986
Dan Kennedy, Daily Times Chronicle - Pinder calls testifying "exhaustive, exhausting" (Acrobat (PDF) 37kB Jul3 06), 23 May 1986
Dan Kennedy, Daily Times Chronicle - Plaintiffs may conclude case today or Monday (Acrobat (PDF) 42kB Jul3 06), 29 May 1986
Dan Kennedy, Daily Times Chronicle