The ComPADRE Collections

Will the egg break?

This page authored by Joel D. Donna, University of Minnesota
Author Profile

This activity has benefited from input through a review and suggestion process.

This activity has benefited from input from faculty educators beyond the author through a review and suggestion process as a part of an activity development workshop. Workshop participants were provided with a set of criteria against which they evaluated each others' activities. For information about the criteria used for this review, see http://serc.carleton.edu/sp/compadre/devactivities/reviewcriteria.html.


This page first made public: Aug 13, 2007

This material is replicated on a number of sites as part of the SERC Pedagogic Service Project

Summary

This is a discrepant event that can be used to help students understand applications of the momentum-impulse theorem. Students are first asked to predict and hypothesize what will happen when an egg is thrown into a sheet. After sharing predictions and hypotheses, a volunteer student will throw the egg into the sheet. Other students make observations and craft explanations of what happened to explain why the egg does not break when it hits the sheet but does break if thrown at a wall. Students will then be asked a series of guiding questions to help them challenge misconceptions and sharpen their understanding of momentum and impulse.

Learning Goals

- Students will be able to explain why the changes in momentum and the associated impulse used to change momentum are identical when two eggs of identical mass and initial velocity are bought to rest by a wall and by a sheet.

- Students will be able to explain how throwing an egg into a fitted sheet causes increase in time which causes a decrease in force required to bring the egg to rest

Context for Use

Educational level: Conceptual Physics Course
Setting: Any
Time required: 10 Minutes
Special equipment: Eggs and a fitted sheet
Pre-requisite knowledge: Students should have a working definition and beginning understanding of momentum, impulse, Newton's laws of motion.

Description and Teaching Materials

Before doing the discrepant event, make sure students have a working understanding of momentum, impulse, and how they are related by the impulse-momentum theorem.

1. Get the students into groups of two. Present these review questions. See student questions (Microsoft Word 30kB Jul30 07) Ask them to work together on these problems. After some time, gather the class together and solicit student answers .

2. Re-derive the impulse/momentum equation by using Newton's Second Law and the linear acceleration equation.

3. Ask for two volunteers and one person to throw an egg. Make a big deal out of getting safety goggles, rain jackets, a mop etc.

4. Before the egg is thrown into the sheet, ask students to individually predict what will happen if an egg is thrown into a sheet. Ask them to hypothesize why they think it will happen. Make sure that this is written down. Have them share this with a partner. Have students share their predictions and reasoning with the class. Encourage them to use physics terms and use drawings.

5. By a show of hands, have students vote if they think that the egg will break. Have the student throw the egg. Slow motion video of this demonstration is available for purchase at http://www.physics.montana.edu/demonstrations/video/1_mechanics/demos/egginsheet.html

6. Have students imagine that an identical egg was thrown at the same speed into the wall. Have them explain to each-other why the egg does not break in the sheet but does in the wall. Solicited a few responses from the class.

7.Guide the students through the following series of questions. For each question have students vote and discuss. See student questions (Microsoft Word 30kB Jul30 07)

8. After this series of questions, guide students to understanding why the egg breaks when it hits the wall but does not when it hits the sheet by using the momentum impulse theorem. See the illustration below. The size of the letters represents the relative sizes of force and time. Do one symbol at a time for the wall and the sheet starting with mass and change in velocity. Reinforce the idea that change in momentum is the same. Move to force by drawing a large force for the wall and a small force for the egg. Egg in Sheet Momentum/Impulse Theorem Ask students what must be true about the relative size of the time in order to have the same changes in momentum. Finally, fill in the time.

9. Ask students to re-explain to each-other how this explains why the egg breaks on the wall but not on the sheet.

student questions (Microsoft Word 30kB Jul30 07)

Teaching Notes and Tips

Safety notes

Make sure that the sheet holders have goggles on and hold the sheet so the egg does not roll out at the bottom.

If an egg breaks and gets on any students , make sure to have students wash hands thoroughly with soap and water.

Have the thrower throw relatively close to the sheet.

Assessment

Conduct informal, formative assessments throughout the review questions and student responses through the demonstration and explanation.

To conduct a more summative assessment, have students complete a ticket to leave. A ticket to leave is a half sheet of paper in which students answer questions on a sheet of paper and hand them to you as they leave the class. See attached questions.

References and Resources

This activity is modified from the "Egg Toss" laboratory investigation found in Conceptual Physical Science Explorations.

High speed footage of this can be found for purchase at physicsdemos.com

High speed photography can by found at Montana Physics Demonstrations