John Diebold: Implementor Extraordinairepublished Jul 6, 2010
In the context of Earth & Mind, John's death has gotten me to thinking about how many different talents are needed to push back the frontiers of knowledge in geosciences...and to wondering whether we are recruiting and fostering the necessary range of talents in the next generation.
When I was writing "To What Extent should Human/Environment Interactions be Included in Science Education?," I dug into the fairly sparse literature on "conative learning goals." As described in Dave Mogk's "Conation" blogpost, "conative" refers to desire to act or striving towards action. If a cognitive learning goal articulates how you want your students to think after instruction, and an affective learning goal states how you want your students to feel, a "conative" learing goal refers to how you want your students to act or strive to act.
This literature quest led me to a book called "The Conative Connection" by Kathy Kolbe. It's a business person's self-help book, written in a breezy style that made it hard for me to take seriously. But I think that it offers an important lesson for decision-makers in science and science education. Kolbe makes the case that humans have four different modes by which they can strive to get stuff done, to make things happen. Her four modes are:
- Fact Finder: inclines towards gathering data, and probing for information; keen at observing. In Fact Finder mode, people evaluate, probe, calculate, inquire, deliberate, prioritize, allocate.
- Follow Thru: methodical and systematic, focused and structured; brings order and efficiency; strong at finding and creating patterns. Planner, designer, systematizer, theorist. In Follow Thru mode, people arrange, plan, design, chart, consolidate, structure, schedule, integrate.
- Quick Start: spontaneous and intuitive, flexible and fluent with ideas; deadline and crisis oriented; needing an atmosphere of challenge and change; with an affinity toward risk. Catalyst, generalist, innovator, entrepreneur, improviser. In Quick Start mode, people brainstorm, contrive, risk, invent, intuit, challenge, devise.
- Implementor: hands-on, craft-oriented; with a strong sense of three-dimensional form, and the ability to deal with the concrete. In implementor mode, people craft, construct, repair, render, demonstrate, shape, mold, build.
I believe that science, and geoscience in particular, needs individuals who excel at each of the four modes. "Fact Finder" is closest to the public's stereotype of what scientists do, gathering data and probing for information. "Follow Thru," with its strong ability to find patterns, is important in our observational science, where the significant patterns of nature can be subtle and hard to detect amid chaos and complexity. "Quick Start" are the people who create paradigm shifts and pioneer new disciplines and subdisciplines. And "Implementors" are the people who create the tools that make it possible for us to extend our human senses to perceive Earth structures and processes that are too big, too small, too fast, too slow, too deep, too far away, too complicated, too dangerous, or outside the frequency bands accessible to our eyes, ears and fingers.
Kolbe claims that the ranks of teachers and professors at all levels from middle school through university are primarily populated by "Fact Finders." This resonates with my experiences in academia. I would argue that one of the secrets underlying the success of geoscience in general, and Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory in particular, is that they have made room for, and appreciated, individuals of all four conative modes. [Full disclosure: I score as a mixture of Quick Start and Follow Thru on Kolbe's self-assessment.]
John Diebold was a spectacular, world-class Implementor. In his weekly report following John's death, Lamont Director Mike Purdy wrote:
I am worried that science and science education aren't providing many on-ramps into science for non-Fact Finder individuals. Consider John's 1967 job interview, as recounted in his "Lamont history."
"Do you like mechanical shit, young man?"
"Do you work on your own car, young man?"
"Do you want to go to sea, young man?" finally,
"Can you come to work on Monday, young man?
Would such a person find his way into geosciences today?
- John Diebold's memoir of his earliest days at Lamont, which begins: "Reader, be warned that most of what follows is sea stories." Beautifully written, by the way.
- John Diebold's home page.
- Official Columbia University obit
- L-DEO Director Mike Purdy's comments on John's passing. will be here
- Dale Chayes' blogpost reminiscing about John. Especially appropriate quote from Barak Obama's inauguration speech: ".... it has been the risk-takers, the doers, the makers of things -- some celebrated, but more often men and women obscure in their labor -- who have carried us up the long, rugged path...."
Spelling Notes: Yes, "conative" has one "n." Weird, isn't it? I thought Kolbe's term "implementor" should be "implementer," with an "e", but I looked it up and it seems that they are both acceptable alternatives for "a person who implements something," so I stuck with Kolbe's "...or." I had a harder time with Kolbe's use of "thru" in place of "through." I stuck with "Follow Thru" because it is a term of art coined by someone else, which means I don't get to decide how I want to spell it. (Surely only a person with Follow Thru in her conative make-up would worry about these details.)
Comment? Start the discussion about John Diebold: Implementor Extraordinaire