Science Review Feedback Form

Thank you for agreeing to conduct a review of InTeGrate curricular materials. The curriculum is expected to help develop a citizenry and workforce that can address environmental and resource issues facing our society. As such, these materials must be scientifically accurate. We are enlisting your assistance in meeting these goals by asking you to review the scientific accuracy of the attached InTeGrate curricular materials.

We ask that you Indicate if any of the following deficiencies are present in the curriculum (provide detailed comments for authors). In your comments for the authors, clearly explain any shortcomings or suggestions. Also, if specific content is flawed, indicate how and where such issues could be rectified. You may either paste your comments directly in this form or use the upload tool at the bottom of this email to upload them in one document. Note that if you choose to provide feedback in the form, you will need to submit it all at once; you cannot save the input and come back to it later.

We ask for your name and email address in case we need to follow up with you, but will keep your comments anonymous when reporting them if you check the box below to indicate you wish to remain anonymous.

Your name:

Email address:

Please withhold my name when reporting my comments thus keeping this feedback anonymous.

Title of module or course reviewed:

Please write your notes for each prompt in the boxes below OR upload them as a single document using the upload tool below.

Issues with description or use of scientific concepts:

Missing essential related or core concept:

Resource clearly neglects to identify assumptions and distinguish between observations/facts and interpretation/hypothesis:

Data and/or materials out of date:

Missing or flawed statistical analyses:

Flawed analogies:

Errors in figures, data or misleading images:

Inappropriate or missing references:

Other comments not captured above (optional):

If you opted to provide feedback in a document rather than directly in the form, please upload that file here.

All uploaded files are public unless you are in a private workspace

Title: A descriptive, human readable title.

e.g. 'Student Handout for Sauerkraut Assignment'

Select the file: Make sure it has an appropriate suffix (e.g. .doc) or specify the type in the Optional Fields below

Description: A very brief description of the file.

Show Optional Fields

File Type:

The system will attempt to determine the correct file type based on the name of the file you've selected. Choosing the correct file type here will override that.

File Name:

e.g. 'student_handout'
This will be the name of the downloaded file. By default the system will generate this based on the title you specified and the type of file. If you specify a name here it will over-ride the automatically generated name. This is generally only useful when uploading file of a type not recognized by the system (not in the list of file types above). In that situation choose File Type: Unknown Binary and include the appropriate suffix in the file name here. e.g. myfile.m3z Avoid spaces or special characters in the file names.

Authorship/Reuse

Either:
I am the author (copyright holder) of the contents of this file and people are allowed to reuse it for non-commercial purposes as long as they give me attribution as described by this creative commons license.
Or

Choose a different authorship/reuse options

Who is the original creator/copyright holder of the information in this file?

Provenance/Acknowledgements

A short description of where the material came from. Include names and institutions of authors and contributors as well as acknowledgment of any work from which this was derived.

Reuse License

The creator/copyright holder must have agreed to allow distribution of this file through this site.
If you are the creator we strongly encourage you to select the CC Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike option.

If none of the above licenses apply describe the conditions under which this material appears on this site as well as any information about reuse beyond this site.

More Information about reuse and choosing a license

Distributing information on the web generally requires the permission of the copyright holder--usually the original creator. Providing the information we request here will help visitors to this site understand the ways in which they may (legally) use what they find.

If you created this file (and haven't signed away your copyright) then we'd encourage you to select the CC Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike option. You'll retain the copyright to your file and can do as you please with it in the future. Through this choice you are also explicitly allowing others to reuse that file as long as they give you attribution, and don't use it for commercial purposes.

If the file (or content within it) was created by others you'll need their permission. If it predates 1923 or was created by a U.S federal employee (as part of their job) it is likely in the public domain (and we can all do as we choose with it). The original author may also have explicitly stated how it may be reused (e.g. through a creative commons license). You can describe the licensing/reuse situation in the box above.

Without permission you should not upload the file. There are several options in this case:

You can contact the original author to get permission.
You can provide a link to (or a description of how to get) the original material rather than uploading it here.
You can find a substitute that isn't encumbered by copyright.
You can create a substitute yourself. Remember, ideas can't be copyrighted, only particular expressions of those ideas. Of course you'll want to give credit the original author.

The Stanford Copyright and Fair Use Center has more good information about copyright as it applies to academic settings.

Name Email

« Previous Page