Teacher Preparation > Resource Collections > Teaching Activities > Be the Block: Working the Geologic Block Diagram as an Inquiry Tool

Be the Block: Working the Geologic Block Diagram as an Inquiry Tool

This activity was originally designed by Eric Pyle and Kathryn Lubker, while at West Virginia University. It has since been expanded and supported by a presentation developed by Dr. Pyle while at James Madison University, and presented at NSTA meetings in Anaheim (2006) and St. Louis (2007).

Summary

The activity is presented as a part of a 5-E learning cycle:
  • Engagement—students are asked to reflect on their prior knowledge of Steno's Principles as well as the social, scientific, and technological climate of the late 18th and early 19th Century England. A few slides about Steno and the industrial age crises in England are presented.
  • Exploration—placed around the room are a series of stratigraphic columns and surface expressions, with lithologies represented by different colored squares of construction paper. Some of these have overprinted on them sedimentary structures or fossils. The columns are placed in such a manner as to represent the corners and the middle of the sides of a block diagram, rendered flat as a cut-out and foldable object. Students then plot the lithologies in order on the block, connecting similar lithologies to reveal not just the cross-sections but also the surface expression. The block is then cut-out and folded into the standard block diagram.
  • Explanation—the structures created by the students are evaluated compared to a master block diagram and corrections made. The remainder of the slide presentation is shared, relating the development of the geologic map by William Smith and its basis in his observations of coal mine shafts, canal excavations, and related fossils.
  • Elaboration—Students are given additional block diagrams, containing only partial information, and asked to infer what would exist in the blank areas.
  • Evaluation—students are given a complete block with more complex structures and asked to design, through inference, a set of columns and surface expressions that would represent the diagram and allow another student to recreate the structures.

Learn more about the course for which this activity was developed.

Learning Goals

Students often have difficulty transposing 2-dimensional information into 3-dimensional space. Using their strengths in 2-D fields (the sides and top of the block), students construct a 3-D object from 2-D knowledge and observations.

The activity is designed to represent a model of Earth science inquiry in which students interpolate and extrapolate, develop and test models through observation, and subsequently test the interpretations derived from those models.

Context for Use

This activity is used to illustrate both historical and methodological positions in the study of the Earth, stressing the importance of dealing with incomplete information, detailed descriptions through observation, and testing models and interpretations in light of new or potentially conflicting information.

Teaching Notes and Tips

This does require a considerable amount of set-up time, no less than 30 minutes once the columns are established and the construction paper cut-out.

Teaching Materials

Related powerpoint presentation (PowerPoint 6.2MB Apr13 07). Not all of the images have been fully credited at this point.

An additional resource is a chapter on inquiry in Earth science, to appear in a pending NSF publication. The version attached is a slightly longer version than will appear in the volume.
Inquiry in the Earth Sciences (Acrobat (PDF) 286kB Apr13 07)

Assessment

Assessment is embedded within the Learning Cycle itself, but summative assessment comes from synthesis writing tasks, requiring students to frame their understandings of this task with other historical representations in the Earth sciences.

References and Resources

A good collection of paper models for block diagrams can be found at:
http://www.fault-analysis-group.ucd.ie/

Several of these have been used in class, blanking out part or all of the information as needed.

Controlled Vocabulary Terms

Subject: Geoscience:Geology:Historical Geology, Education, Geoscience:Geology:Geomorphology, Structural Geology
Resource Type: Activities:Classroom Activity
Ready for Use: Ready to Use

See more Teaching Activities »