> > Cell parts

« Implementation Discussion 1

Cell parts  

1: Kristina Karl 04:48 PM Dec 9 2008 1017:3032 edittextuser=1671 post_id=3032 initial_post_id=0 thread_id=1017 Reply to this post

I am still working on the original investigation that I posted in the fall. This project will be my "second investigation" as I need a couple more data points prior to analysis. I have already implemented an edited version of Carla's "Sizing up cells."

Attachments:


Student handout for Sizing up cells (Microsoft Word 176kB Dec9 08)

2: Kristina Karl 04:49 PM Dec 9 2008 1017:3033 edittextuser=1671 post_id=3033 initial_post_id=0 thread_id=1017 Reply to this post

3: Kristina Karl 04:53 PM Dec 9 2008 1017:3034 edittextuser=1671 post_id=3034 initial_post_id=0 thread_id=1017 Reply to this post

This is an example of student output. In the future, I would spend more time formatting the graphs (gridlines, etc), but for this purpose, students were just excited to have made a graph so quickly!!

Attachments:


Cell measurement Excel graph (Excel 23kB Dec9 08)

4: Kristina Karl 05:27 PM Dec 9 2008 1017:3035 edittextuser=1671 post_id=3035 initial_post_id=0 thread_id=1017 Reply to this post

Attachments:


Investigation Template (Microsoft Word 359kB Dec9 08)

5: Patricia Davis 06:39 PM Dec 11 2008 1017:3050 edittextuser=2233 post_id=3050 initial_post_id=0 thread_id=1017 Reply to this post

Kristina,
You are absolutely right. Kids love to look at how many kinds or sizes there are in their own cells. It does broaden there area of understanding.

6: Celeste Cruse 12:15 PM Dec 12 2008 1017:3063 edittextuser=1699 post_id=3063 initial_post_id=0 thread_id=1017 Reply to this post

I did this with my students too (adapted Kristina's adaptation of Carla's) and it still needs some fine tuning. I found that I needed a big block of time with the computers (3-4 days)to get max learning from this investigation. They do like Excel but get confused when measuring with ImageJ easily - biggest hurdle is getting them to set scale before every different picture/measurement.

7: Marie Wisz 04:21 PM Dec 14 2008 1017:3092 edittextuser=1660 post_id=3092 initial_post_id=0 thread_id=1017 Reply to this post

Kristina, this looks interesting since I teach cells as well. In grade seven, we review cell organelles and functions, however, cell size is only mentioned. Students would benefit from comparing various cells and creating a graph as a visual presentation. Are two class periods adequate for this lesson, or would I need to schedule additional computer time? Our classes are about the same length of time. Also, do you have web sites available to locate scaled cell pictures? This lesson looks great!

8: Kristina Karl 08:51 AM Dec 18 2008 1017:3130 edittextuser=1671 post_id=3130 initial_post_id=0 thread_id=1017 Reply to this post

Marie, I would suggest providing at least 3 full class periods for this. Additionally, if they have already had practice using ImageJ (just learning how to use the tools) would help them. As Celeste mentioned, they constantly forget to set the scale for EACH picture.
I used pictures from the website: http://www.bioscience.heacademy.ac.uk/imagebank/search/Fullimage.aspx?IDvalues=1363
where you can pick and choose from many images, however, some of the images are difficult for the 7th graders who are just learning about cell parts. I have found great pictures through google images, and I even took some pictures myself with an USB microscope. The hardest part is finding pictures with the scale bar!

Join the Discussion

In order to post to this discussion you need to be logged in.

Create a New Account

It only takes 20 seconds and it's free!

Login with your current account

Email Address:  

Password:        

Forgot your password?

« Implementation Discussion 1

« AML Excel Spreadsheet Survey       Student use of Excel through Objects Materials »