Cutting Edge > Topics > Climate Change > Ideas for Teaching about Ice Cores > Climate change and interpreting ice core data

This is a partially developed activity description. It is included in the collection because it contains ideas useful for teaching even though it is incomplete.

Climate Change and Interpreting Ice Core Data

This activity was developed during the Teaching Climate Change Using Ice Core Data workshop, held in June 2008.
Contributed by Jim Botti, Carlyn Buckler, Makeeya Hazelton, Carrie Morrill and George Stone

Topic: Interpret and accurately use graphed data

Course Type: upper level

Description

Individual Study: Look at a simple graph; what conclusions, if any, can you draw given the data?

Teams Study: Talk about the graph from individual study. Review axis of graphs; What do you know about graphs? What conclusions can you come to about the graph? Did everyone have the same interpretation?

Individual Study: Look at four time series graphs:

CO2, volcanic and solar forcings over the past 1000 years
Three different temperature records over the past 2000 years

Ultimately, we would make our own time series graphs (3 total) using NOAA data points. These would include:

  1. graphing variations in solar radiation,
  2. volcanic activity, and
  3. CO2 levels vs. temperature change over the last 1000 years.
How would you interpret each of these graphs?
Looking at all the graphs, what conclusions, if any, can you make?

Team Study:
  1. Discuss each team's interpretations of the data.
  2. Do all interpretations agree?
  3. Why or why not?
  4. What additional questions do students have about the data?

Goals

Interpret and accurately use graphed data:

  1. understanding
    • X and Y Axis
    • correlation vs causation
    • extrapolating Big Ideas from multiple data sets
  2. making an argument based on evidence
    • units

Assessment

If they came to the correct conclusions...

References

NOAA Paleoclimatology page: What are climate forcings?
NOAA Paleoclimatology page: Paleoclimatic Data for the Last 2000 Years


« Bring it Home       Debate: Be it resolved that global warning is anthropogenic, not natural »